Restaurant

Mi Tocaya Antojería

Name: Mi Tocaya Antojería
Address: 2800 W Logan Blvd, Chicago, IL, 60647, US
Telephone: (872) 315-3947
Price range: $$

Mexican•Chicago•$$•Check restaurant site

BIB GOURMAND

Mi Tocaya Antojería is one of the best mexican restaurants in Chicago for date night, especially if you want a strong option in Chicago.

Diana Dávila's Logan Square room makes its argument quietly, then refuses to let go.

Editorial review updated•Jul 28, 2026

Diana Dávila's Logan Square room makes its argument quietly, then refuses to let go. Mi Tocaya isn't a special-occasion temple in the usual sense — there's no procession of courses, no hushed reverence. What it offers instead is a chef working from memory and conviction, and the cheque ($30–40 per person) reflects an antojería rather than a tasting menu. That distinction matters: you come for plates that earn their place individually. Peanut Butter Y Lengua, braised beef tongue under a thick peanut salsa with radishes, is the dish people travel for, and the homage to her uncle reads on the plate, not just the menu card. The Espaghetti Con Crema Poblana — toasted fideo in poblano sauce with crab and egg — is the kind of personal cooking that explains the Bib Gourmand and the Bon Appétit nod from 2017. The room is small, colorful, evening-only, and warmer than the awards suggest. Service runs informal. This is not a blowout; it's a thoughtful dinner that justifies the trip on the strength of its ideas. Reserve, arrive hungry, and order generously across the table.

James Whitfield, Restaurant Critic

Methodology•Chicago guides•Editorial team•Report outdated information

Date Night Fine Dining

Visit Website Get Directions

Taste ID

Rate this restaurant

Start with one score. Add details or a review when you want to help other diners.

Bib Gourmand

Taste Score 8.8/10

Rating (Google) 9.2

1,150 reviews

Chicago

At a glance

The fastest read on whether this place fits tonight.

8.8/10

Taste Score

Google 9.2 from 1,150 reviews

Michelin

BIB GOURMAND

Best for

Date Night and Fine Dining

Price and pace

Moderate spend | Check restaurant site

Neighborhood

Chicago | 2800 W Logan Blvd, Chicago, IL 60647, USA

Hours

Check restaurant site

Price

Moderate spend

Taste Score

8.8/10

Phone

(872) 315-3947

Inside the restaurant

Photos of Mi Tocaya Antojería

1 photo

Menu and ordering

Mi Tocaya Antojería menu: what to order

Start with the dishes below, drawn from the restaurant details and TastyPals notes available on this page. Mi Tocaya Antojería is listed in the Moderate spend price range. Menus, availability, and prices can change, so confirm current details before visiting.

Peanut Butter Y Lengua

Espaghetti Con Crema Poblana

Guisado de Nopalitos

Steak Burrito

Why go

What makes Mi Tocaya Antojería worth the move

Mi Tocaya Antojería is an easy yes when you want somewhere that feels considered rather than fussy. It also holds a 9.2 rating across 1,150 Google reviews.

What to know fast

Public rating

9.2 from 1,150 Google reviews

Best for

Date Night and Fine Dining

Style

Mexican in Chicago

Spend

Moderate spend | Check restaurant site

Best for

Date Night Fine Dining

Know before you go

Google rating: 9.2 from 1,150 reviews

Price point: $$

Website linked on this page

Phone number available

TastyPals Reviews

What diners are saying

0 diner reviews · reviewed by James Whitfield for Mi Tocaya Antojería

Be the first TastyPals diner to reviewFirst-hand reviews are moderated before appearing publicly.

Google snapshot

9.2 from 1,150 reviews

TastyPals notes

Editorial review by James Whitfield

No diner notes for Mi Tocaya Antojería yet.

Dhanteraz Indian Fusion occupies the former Savannah Supper Club space on West Roscoe Street, and the transformation matters: what was once a supper club is now one of Roscoe Village's most talked-about Indian kitchens, a BYOB spot where…

More TastyPals-reviewed restaurants in Chicago

Continue exploring restaurants that passed the same editorial quality gate.

Plan the visit

Quick details

Visit Website Directions

Address: 2800 W Logan Blvd, Chicago, IL 60647, USA
Phone: (872) 315-3947
Price: $$
TastyPals score: 8.8/10
Hours: Check restaurant site
Google rating: 9.2 (1,150 reviews)
Cuisine: Mexican
Michelin: BIB GOURMAND
Neighborhood: Chicago

Read guide

Frequently asked questions

What cuisine does Mi Tocaya Antojería serve?

Mi Tocaya Antojería is a Mexican restaurant located in Chicago, Chicago. Diana Dávila's Logan Square room makes its argument quietly, then refuses to let go.

What is Mi Tocaya Antojería best for?

Mi Tocaya Antojería is best for date night, fine dining. Mi Tocaya Antojería is an easy yes when you want somewhere that feels considered rather than fussy. It also holds a 9.2 rating across 1,150 Google reviews.

How much does it cost to eat at Mi Tocaya Antojería?

Mi Tocaya Antojería is in the Moderate spend price range ($$). Google rating: 9.2 from 1,150 reviews

What should I order at Mi Tocaya Antojería?

Start with Peanut Butter Y Lengua, Espaghetti Con Crema Poblana, Guisado de Nopalitos and Steak Burrito. These dishes are shown from TastyPals notes or restaurant data on this page.

Is Mi Tocaya Antojería worth visiting?

Mi Tocaya Antojería holds a 9.2 Google rating from 1,150 reviews. Mi Tocaya Antojería is an easy yes when you want somewhere that feels considered rather than fussy. It also holds a 9.2 rating across 1,150 Google reviews.

Where is Mi Tocaya Antojería located?

Mi Tocaya Antojería is located at 2800 W Logan Blvd, Chicago, IL 60647, USA. Directions are available via Google Maps.

What are Mi Tocaya Antojería's hours?

Mi Tocaya Antojería's listed hours are Check restaurant site. We recommend checking directly before visiting as hours may vary on holidays.

Is Mi Tocaya Antojería good for a date night?

Yes — Mi Tocaya Antojería is tagged for date night dining. Mi Tocaya Antojería is an easy yes when you want somewhere that feels considered rather than fussy. It also holds a 9.2 rating across 1,150 Google reviews.

Explore more in Chicago

Best New Openings in ChicagoSource-checked recent openings worth knowing now.

Ready to dine?

Book a table at Mi Tocaya Antojería

Check availability on the restaurant's official site.

Visit Website

TastyPals for iPhone + Android

See your Taste Match in TastyPals

Use the web for editorial context, then explore Mi Tocaya Antojería and similar picks in the app when you want a more personal Chicago restaurant shortlist.

Free to downloadPersonalized Taste IDiPhone + Android

TastyPals personalized restaurant discovery app screen

Website