Restaurant

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview

Name: Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview
Address: 3409 N Broadway, Chicago, IL, 60657, US
Telephone: (224) 656-4732
Price range: $$$$

Pizza•Chicago•$$$$

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is one of the best pizza restaurants in Chicago for group dinner, especially if you want a strong option in Chicago.

Milly's Pizza in the Pan has built a focused reputation in Lakeview by treating the Chicago pan format with a seriousness the category rarely receives.

Editorial review updated•Jul 28, 2026

Milly's Pizza in the Pan has built a focused reputation in Lakeview by treating the Chicago pan format with a seriousness the category rarely receives. Where most pan-pizza operations treat the dough as a vehicle, the kitchen here has apparently made it the point — a distinction that, according to consistent accounts, separates this from the operations that gave the format its generic reputation. The signature pan pizza is where that philosophy is most legible: diners report a properly fermented crust that holds structural integrity through the full depth of cheese and toppings, crisped at the edges without collapsing into density. That is a harder technical outcome than it looks, and it is reportedly the reason the room has developed the following it has. The menu also centers on a seasonal topping pie, which suggests a kitchen willing to test the format's flexibility rather than default to a fixed combination. The practical approach, based on how regulars describe their ordering, is to take two or three different pie configurations across a group rather than consolidating into one large option — the kitchen's judgment about topping pairings is apparently one of the more considered elements of the experience, and it is worth testing across combinations. The house salad is well-regarded as a counterpoint to the richness that the pan format inevitably carries; a composed reprieve rather than an afterthought. Milly's functions as a Lakeview neighborhood pizza destination suited to a casual group dinner or any occasion that calls for something more deliberate than standard delivery. Walk-ins are reportedly manageable on weeknights; weekend visits benefit from calling ahead. The move is two pans to share and a salad alongside — the format, done this carefully, carries the meal.

Giovanni Ricci, Italian Food Editor

Methodology•Chicago guides•Editorial team•Report outdated information

Group Dinner

Visit Website Get Directions

Taste ID

Rate this restaurant

Start with one score. Add details or a review when you want to help other diners.

Taste Score 8.3/10

Rating (Google) 9.4

34 reviews

Chicago

At a glance

The fastest read on whether this place fits tonight.

8.3/10

Taste Score

Google 9.4 from 34 reviews

Best for

Group Dinner

Price and pace

Splurge territory

Neighborhood

Chicago | 3409 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60657, USA

Price

Splurge territory

Taste Score

8.3/10

Phone

(224) 656-4732

Inside the restaurant

Photos of Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview

1 photo

What to order

Signature dishes at Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview

Signature pan pizza

Seasonal topping pie

House salad

Why go

What makes Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview worth the move

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is a clean first click in Chicago when you want a pizza option you can trust. Signature pan pizza and Seasonal topping pie also give you a decent sense of the menu. It also holds a 9.4 rating across 34 Google reviews.

What to know fast

Public rating

9.4 from 34 Google reviews

Best for

Group Dinner

Style

Pizza in Chicago

Spend

Splurge territory

Best for

Group Dinner

Know before you go

Google rating: 9.4 from 34 reviews

Popular dishes: Signature pan pizza, Seasonal topping pie, House salad

Website linked on this page

Phone number available

TastyPals Reviews

What diners are saying

0 diner reviews · reviewed by Giovanni Ricci for Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview

Google snapshot

9.4 from 34 reviews

TastyPals notes

Editorial review by Giovanni Ricci

Dhanteraz Indian Fusion occupies the former Savannah Supper Club space on West Roscoe Street, and the transformation matters: what was once a supper club is now one of Roscoe Village's most talked-about Indian kitchens, a BYOB spot where…

More TastyPals-reviewed restaurants in Chicago

Continue exploring restaurants that passed the same editorial quality gate.

Plan the visit

Quick details

Visit Website Directions

Address: 3409 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60657, USA
Phone: (224) 656-4732
Price: $$$$
TastyPals score: 8.3/10
Google rating: 9.4 (34 reviews)
Cuisine: Pizza
Neighborhood: Chicago

Read guide

Frequently asked questions

What cuisine does Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview serve?

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is a Pizza restaurant located in Chicago, Chicago. Milly's Pizza in the Pan has built a focused reputation in Lakeview by treating the Chicago pan format with a seriousness the category rarely receives.

What is Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview best for?

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is best for group dinner. Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is a clean first click in Chicago when you want a pizza option you can trust. Signature pan pizza and Seasonal topping pie also give you a decent sense of the menu. It also holds a 9.4 rating across 34 Google reviews.

How much does it cost to eat at Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview?

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is in the Splurge territory price range ($$$$). Google rating: 9.4 from 34 reviews

What should I order at Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview?

Start with Signature pan pizza, Seasonal topping pie and House salad. These dishes are shown from TastyPals notes or restaurant data on this page.

Is Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview worth visiting?

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview holds a 9.4 Google rating from 34 reviews. Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is a clean first click in Chicago when you want a pizza option you can trust. Signature pan pizza and Seasonal topping pie also give you a decent sense of the menu. It also holds a 9.4 rating across 34 Google reviews.

Where is Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview located?

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview is located at 3409 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60657, USA. Directions are available via Google Maps.

Explore more in Chicago

Best New Openings in ChicagoSource-checked recent openings worth knowing now.

Ready to dine?

Book a table at Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview

Check availability on the restaurant's official site.

Visit Website

TastyPals for iPhone

See your Taste Match in TastyPals

Use the web for editorial context, then explore Milly’s Pizza In The Pan- Lakeview and similar picks in the app when you want a more personal Chicago restaurant shortlist.

Free to downloadPersonalized Taste IDiOS 16.4 or later

Google Play coming soon.

TastyPals personalized restaurant discovery app screen

Website