1
Google
Pizza•East Village•value
Nuovo York Pizza
Atalay Mali came to pizza the way most people don't — through chemical engineering.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.6
Based on 1630 reviews
Pizza · casual night
Best Pizza for casual night in New York
Pizza restaurants in New York that work well for casual night — sorted by rating and curated for occasion fit.
13 restaurantsUpdated July 2026
Top Pizza picks for casual night
Fast answers for diners comparing pizza restaurants for casual night in New York.
2
Google
Pizza•West Village•value
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village is a sensible pizza call in West Village in New York when you want something that usually lands well.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.4
Based on 3408 reviews
3
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Roma Pizza & restaurant
Roma Pizza & restaurant is an easy pizza option in New York to suggest without needing a long explanation.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.4
Based on 1521 reviews
4
Pizza•Bushwick•value
Lucky Charlie
The oldest coal oven in America sits inside a 42-seat room on Irving Avenue in Bushwick, and that single fact tells you almost everything about Lucky Charlie's ambitions.
Bushwick dinnercasual nightlate night
Read restaurant page
9.4
Based on 252 reviews
5
Google
Pizza•New York•value
NY Pizza Suprema
NY Pizza Suprema is a dependable pizza option that a lot of diners already know and return to.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 8587 reviews
6
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Kesté Pizza e Vino
Here's the thesis on Kesté: Roberto Caporuscio trained directly under the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana in Naples, and the downtown Manhattan room he brought that education back to is about as unpretentious as a serious pizza oper…
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 3357 reviews
7
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Capizzi
Capizzi has a reputation built on exactly the kind of restraint that New York's noisier pizza spots tend to forget is a skill.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 2399 reviews
8
Google
Pizza•Midtown•value
Don Antonio
What Don Antonio is doing in Midtown deserves more attention than the neighborhood usually pays to pizza history.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 2165 reviews
9
Pizza•Bushwick•value
Ops
Ops doesn't announce itself, which is part of the point.
Bushwick dinnercasual nightlate night
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 867 reviews
10
Google
Pizza•Midtown•value
See No Evil Pizza
See No Evil Pizza is an easy pizza option in Midtown in New York to suggest without needing a long explanation.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.2
Based on 376 reviews
11
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Best Pizza
Best Pizza in Williamsburg is not being ironic with the name, and that straightforwardness extends to everything about the place.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.0
Based on 2088 reviews
12
Google
Pizza•Flatiron•value
Joe's Pizza Broadway
Joe's Pizza on Broadway is, by all accounts, a deliberate act of restraint in a neighborhood that has largely forgotten how to be cheap.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
8.8
Based on 25593 reviews
13
Google
Pizza•SoHo•value
Lombardi's
Lombardi's is a dependable pizza option in SoHo that a lot of diners already know and return to.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
8.4
Based on 8971 reviews
Common questions
What are the best Pizza restaurants for casual night in New York?
Top Pizza restaurants for casual night in New York include Nuovo York Pizza, L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village, Roma Pizza & restaurant. TastyPals curates these based on occasion tags, Google ratings, and editorial judgment.
Is Pizza good for casual night in New York?
Yes — New York has 13 Pizza restaurants rated highly for casual night. Nuovo York Pizza is among the top picks with a 9.6 Google rating.
Get the App
Find the right Pizza spot for casual night
Compare Pizza restaurants for casual night on the web, then get personalized picks in the app.
Personalized city picksCleaner shortlistsBuilt for iPhone and Android
TastyPalsTonight
Your taste. Our picks.
Smarter follow-through after the guide: better restaurant context, quicker narrowing, less second-guessing.
For tonight
Date night spots with warm rooms and polished service
Next step
Keep exploring in the app when you want a tighter shortlist