1
Google
Pizza•East Village•value
Nuovo York Pizza
Atalay Mali came to pizza the way most people don't — through chemical engineering.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.6 Google
9.6
1,630 Google reviews
GuideUpdated July 15, 2026
13 Best Pizza Restaurants in New York
The 13 best pizza restaurants in New York, sorted by rating and curated by TastyPals editors.
The best pizza restaurants in New York are Nuovo York Pizza, L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village, Roma Pizza & restaurant, and more. Start with Nuovo York Pizza if you want the strongest overall first pick.
Google
Top picks at a glance
Who this guide is for
This guide covers the highest-rated pizza restaurants in New York. The picks are sorted by Google rating and review volume to give you a reliable shortlist. Picks span East Village, West Village and New York.
Quick picks
Nuovo York Pizza
Pizza • East Village
Atalay Mali came to pizza the way most people don't — through chemical engineering.
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village
Pizza • West Village
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village is a sensible pizza call in West Village in New York when you want something that usually lands well.
Roma Pizza & restaurant
Pizza • New York
Roma Pizza & restaurant is an easy pizza option in New York to suggest without needing a long explanation.
Editorial details
On this page
- 1. Nuovo York PizzaView →
- 2. L’industrie Pizzeria - West VillageView →
- 3. Roma Pizza & restaurantView →
- 4. NY Pizza SupremaView →
- 5. John's of Bleecker StreetView →
- 6. Kesté Pizza e VinoView →
- 7. CapizziView →
- 8. Don AntonioView →
- 9. Best PizzaView →
- 10. Joe's Pizza BroadwayView →
- 11. Lombardi'sView →
- 12. LucaliView →
How the restaurants compare
Google
Nuovo York Pizza
East Village • Pizza
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
Price
value
Best for
casual night
Mood
East Village
Google
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village
West Village • Pizza
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
Price
value
Best for
casual night
Mood
West Village
Google
Roma Pizza & restaurant
New York • Pizza
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
Price
value
Best for
casual night
Mood
Casual
Google
NY Pizza Suprema
New York • Pizza
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
Price
value
Best for
casual night
Mood
Casual
How we chose
We looked for restaurants that feel like a strong fit for the guide topic, not just the most obvious names in the city. The shortlist favors rooms with clear mood, dependable pacing, and enough distinction to help someone decide faster. Read our full methodology →
Room tone
Lighting, pace, and general energy all need to support the reason someone clicked this guide.
Food fit
We favored restaurants that feel best suited for the moment, not just restaurants with broad reputation.
Useful range
The final list tries to give readers enough variation in neighborhood, price, and style to compare real options.
12 ranked picks
Nuovo York Pizza — Atalay Mali came to pizza the way most people don't — through chemical engineering. Before opening Nuovo York on East 9th Street in the East Village, he reportedly spent years working out dough fermentation at a near-obsessive level, landing on a 72-hour process that's become the shop's calling card. The logic behind it is real: longer fermentation develops complexity and makes the dough easier to digest, and by most accounts the result is a crust that's noticeably lighter than what you'd pull from your average New York slice counter. When a guy with a chemistry degree builds strong opinions about sauce viscosity into his business plan, that's usually a sign the dough is the actual product.
The menu is built around slices, and the two that consistently come up are the Spinach Mushroom and the Pepperoni Pesto. The Spinach Mushroom is understood to be the cleaner expression of what Mali is doing — earthy toppings against a sauce that diners describe as bright and well-balanced, the kind of combination that lets the crust make its case. The Pepperoni Pesto is the odder pairing and reportedly the more divisive one, though it has its advocates who find the herbal richness works better against cured meat than you'd expect. Beyond slices, the menu stretches into Sicilian squares named after New York landmarks and year-round heart-shaped pies — concepts that could read as gimmicky but make more sense once you understand the fermented crust is the throughline holding all of it together.
For a price-level-one spot in the East Village, the ambition on display is hard to dismiss. No reservations, no ceremony — you walk in, grab slices, and the argument more or less makes itself. View restaurant →
Get the App
Save these spots to your New York list
Keep the shortlist handy in the TastyPals app and find similar restaurants across New York.
Personalized city picksCleaner shortlistsBuilt for iPhone and Android
TastyPalsTonight
Your taste. Our picks.
Smarter follow-through after the guide: better restaurant context, quicker narrowing, less second-guessing.
For tonight
Date night spots with warm rooms and polished service
Next step
Keep exploring in the app when you want a tighter shortlist
John's of Bleecker Street — John's of Bleecker Street is a genuinely unusual place to walk into — a converted chapel in the West Village that has housed a coal-fired brick oven since 1929. The booths are reportedly carved with decades of accumulated initials, the room smells of char and garlic before you even sit down, and the whole operation runs on a philosophy that hasn't shifted much in roughly a century: whole pies only, no slices, cash preferred, no apologies. For a city that reinvents its pizza identity every eighteen months, that kind of institutional stubbornness is its own statement.
The menu is focused almost to the point of severity, which is the point. The Margherita is the anchor — coal-fired pies at this temperature are known for producing a thin, blistered crust with edge char that conventional ovens simply can't replicate, and diners consistently point to the brightness of the tomato and the way the mozzarella behaves under that heat. The Piccante Pie has a reputation for heat that builds rather than announces itself immediately. The Boom Pie is described as the more adventurous order on the menu, for anyone who wants to move past the classics. On the non-pizza side, the Garlic Bread is reportedly blunt and unapologetic in exactly the way garlic bread should be, and John's Meatball Dish draws consistent comparisons to old-school Italian-American cooking done without fuss or flourish.
Practical notes: weeknight visits are the move for anyone trying to avoid a significant wait. Arriving at or near opening improves your chances of landing a booth, which is reportedly where the room's character comes through most clearly. Budget roughly $20 per person and bring cash to keep things moving. View restaurant →
5
Google
Pizza•West Village•$$
John's of Bleecker Street
John's of Bleecker Street is a genuinely unusual place to walk into — a converted chapel in the West Village that has housed a coal-fired brick oven since 1929.
pizzacheap eatsitalian
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.2 Google
9.2
8,296 Google reviews
Kesté Pizza e Vino — Here's the thesis on Kesté: Roberto Caporuscio trained directly under the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana in Naples, and the downtown Manhattan room he brought that education back to is about as unpretentious as a serious pizza operation gets. The price point is genuinely democratic, the space is small, and the clientele reportedly runs from curious tourists to West Village regulars who've quietly made it a standing appointment. What Kesté is known for is treating Neapolitan tradition as a method with consequences — not a marketing angle you slap on a menu.
The approach before you even get to pizza is worth noting. The Fritto Misto Napoletano is consistently cited as a strong opening move — a fried starter rooted in Neapolitan street-food tradition, the kind of dish designed to arrive hot and demand your attention immediately. The Montanara is where Kesté distinguishes itself early: fried dough finished in the oven, a technique that reportedly produces a layered crust unlike anything a straight bake delivers, and one that diners keep coming back to describe as the right introduction to the kitchen's thinking. The Truffle Burrata Pizza is the headline act — the Home Made Truffle Burrata appears on its own as a standalone, but on a leopard-spotted Neapolitan crust it's what most reviewers lead with when explaining why this place has the reputation it does. The Ragù Napoletano rounds out the menu with a pasta option that gets less attention than the pizzas and, by most accounts, deserves more.
Practical reality: the room fills fast on weekends and the wait is not optional, it's just the math. Book ahead. Kesté represents some of the higher-ceiling pizza available in New York at a price that doesn't require negotiating the bill. View restaurant →
6
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Kesté Pizza e Vino
Here's the thesis on Kesté: Roberto Caporuscio trained directly under the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana in Naples, and the downtown Manhattan room he brought that education back to is about as unpretentious as a serious pizza oper…
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.2 Google
9.2
3,357 Google reviews
Capizzi — Capizzi has a reputation built on exactly the kind of restraint that New York's noisier pizza spots tend to forget is a skill. This is a price-level-one operation with a tight menu and no apparent interest in impressing you with its square footage or concept — which, in a city full of both, reads as a genuine point of view. The kitchen centers on Italian-American fundamentals: antipasti and pizza, done with enough seriousness that diners consistently come back to the same handful of dishes rather than working through a sprawling six-page rotation. The room is reportedly no-frills, and the whole setup seems designed around feeding people well rather than staging an experience around them.
Before any pizza lands, the fried antipasti are where Capizzi apparently builds its case. The Burrata Fritta is widely noted for its contrast between a structured exterior and a soft, yielding interior — the kind of result that requires real attention to temperature and timing. The Arancini Spinaci have a reputation for density that suggests the filling isn't being stretched thin, and the Fried Artichokes round out the opening with bitterness and crunch, keeping the lineup from going monotonous. On the pizza side, the Prosciutto & Arugula is known for executing a classic combination correctly — the arugula reportedly hits the oven at a point where it lands between raw and fully wilted, and the prosciutto crisps at the edges. The Margherita is built simply enough that the Hot Honey listed on the menu reads as the right optional addition rather than a distraction.
Practical intel: the consensus is to anchor with two antipasti before your pizza rather than stacking every fried option at once. Earlier in the evening gets you a seat with less maneuvering. If you're ordering the Hot Honey, ask for it on the side. View restaurant →
7
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Capizzi
Capizzi has a reputation built on exactly the kind of restraint that New York's noisier pizza spots tend to forget is a skill.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.2 Google
9.2
2,399 Google reviews
Don Antonio — What Don Antonio is doing in Midtown deserves more attention than the neighborhood usually pays to pizza history. This is a Neapolitan house that has built its entire identity around the montanara — the centuries-old tradition of frying dough before finishing it in the oven — at a moment when most of New York still treats fried pizza as a novelty rather than a lineage. In a part of the city better known for grab-and-go slices, Don Antonio is quietly making the case that pizza has a past worth respecting, and at a price point that makes the argument genuinely hard to ignore.
The menu centers on that commitment in a way that's rare even by downtown standards. The La Montanara Classica is the thesis: dough that's reportedly fried until it puffs into a light, crisp shell, then topped simply enough that the technique has nowhere to hide. The Montanara Genovese builds on the same base with a slow-braised onion ragù — sweet, deeply savory, and known for its contrast against the fried crust. The fried program extends well beyond pizza: Giorgia's Fritto Misto is the kitchen's take on a proper mixed fry, the kind diners consistently describe as requiring immediate attention. The Calzone Fritto is a sealed, gilded pocket that regulars tend to eat with their hands, and correctly so. And the Focaccia, Burro e Alici — focaccia with butter and anchovy — signals a kitchen that understands its audience: people who want salt, fat, and something that tastes like it came from somewhere real.
The practical move is to anchor any order around at least one montanara and one fried starter before considering anything else on the menu. Lunch is the lower-friction window for getting a table; weeknight dinners are livelier but reportedly manageable. Whatever you do, skip delivery — fried dough is a right-now proposition, and this food is meant to be eaten in the room. View restaurant →
8
Google
Pizza•Midtown•value
Don Antonio
What Don Antonio is doing in Midtown deserves more attention than the neighborhood usually pays to pizza history.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.2 Google
9.2
2,165 Google reviews
Best Pizza — Best Pizza in Williamsburg is not being ironic with the name, and that straightforwardness extends to everything about the place. It's a counter-service operation that applies genuine conviction to what most spots treat as an afterthought — the neighborhood slice. The whole premise here is that a well-made, affordable pie deserves as much attention as anything fancier and more expensive, and from what regulars and food writers consistently report, the room earns that position. No tablecloths, no reservations, no theater. Just pizza at a price point that will make you question your recent spending habits.
The menu centers on a tight lineup of fundamentals done with real care. The Cheese Pie 20" is the flagship and carries a reputation for crust that diners describe as properly chewy with intentional char — the kind of thing that comes from someone actually watching the oven, not just setting a timer. The sauce is reportedly tomato-forward without being aggressive, the mozzarella behaving the way it's supposed to. The White Pie 20" is consistently flagged as the insider order: creamy, restrained, a different argument for what pizza can be. The Garlic Knots have their own following, known for being pull-apart soft and generously glossed. The Italian Combo Hero and Meatball Hero round out the menu as serious lunch moves — not afterthoughts, but sandwiches that hold up on their own terms.
Practical notes: the 20-inch whole pie format is what most regulars recommend over slices, since the crust apparently holds its structure better at that scale. Weekends get crowded fast, so going early is the move. The sidewalk is right there if you miscalculate. View restaurant →
9
Google
Pizza•New York•value
Best Pizza
Best Pizza in Williamsburg is not being ironic with the name, and that straightforwardness extends to everything about the place.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
9.0 Google
9.0
2,088 Google reviews
Joe's Pizza Broadway — Joe's Pizza on Broadway is, by all accounts, a deliberate act of restraint in a neighborhood that has largely forgotten how to be cheap. The Flatiron has plenty of spots happy to charge you double digits for a slice dressed up with imported this and artisanal that — Joe's is the counter-argument, and it has been making that argument for decades. What it's known for is the kind of New York pizza that predates the discourse: no narrative required, no tasting notes, no hydration percentages on the menu board. Just a counter, a fast transaction, and a slice that reportedly does exactly what a slice is supposed to do.
The menu centers on three things worth knowing about. The Cheese Pizza is the benchmark — the one diners and food writers consistently point to when they talk about what a plain slice should be in this city. The Pepperoni Pizza follows the same logic, with pepperoni reported to be the kind that curls at the edges rather than laying flat and apologetic. And the Sicilian Pizza offers a thicker, square-cut alternative for anyone who wants something with a little more heft — it has its own following among regulars who find the standard round-pie format insufficiently serious. None of these are complicated propositions, which is precisely the point.
In a district where lunch can quietly become a financial event, Joe's price level stays at the floor — it is widely regarded as one of the more honest transactions you can make in the area. It's a walk-in, counter-service situation, so expect to eat standing or moving. Broadway location, Flatiron, open late enough to matter. Go hungry, keep it simple, skip the napkins until you actually need them. View restaurant →
10
Google
Pizza•Flatiron•value
Joe's Pizza Broadway
Joe's Pizza on Broadway is, by all accounts, a deliberate act of restraint in a neighborhood that has largely forgotten how to be cheap.
Pizzacasual nighttakeout
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
8.8 Google
8.8
25,593 Google reviews
Lucali — Mark Iacono's Carroll Gardens storefront has accumulated the kind of reputation that makes people build itineraries around a pizza dinner — which is, depending on your threshold for hype, either a warning or an endorsement. By most accounts it is the latter. Lucali is consistently ranked among the city's finest pizzerias, and the critical consensus, sustained over years rather than a single season of attention, suggests the operation has not coasted on its name. The menu is deliberately narrow: a pizza and a calzone, nothing more. That restraint is itself a statement about what the kitchen believes it does well.
The pizza is reportedly built on a thin crust fired in a wood oven, topped with what regulars describe as an uncommonly clean tomato base and fresh mozzarella applied without excess — a preparation understood to be in close dialogue with Neapolitan tradition without being a strict replica of it. The calzone carries an equivalent reputation and is, by diner consensus, not a side order but a co-equal reason to visit. Ordering both appears to be the standard approach rather than a point of indulgence. BYOB and cash-only policies are in effect, neither of which are incidental details — they shape the entire register of the evening, pulling it toward something more like a neighbourhood ritual than a restaurant transaction.
Practical realities: the wait outside the Carroll Gardens storefront is well-documented and frequently extends beyond any reasonable estimate. Arriving early is the only reliable mitigation. The room is plain by design; the atmosphere reported by diners is a function of the crowd and the BYO wine rather than any deliberate interior gesture. At a price point that reportedly keeps the full meal under forty dollars, the value proposition — if you have the patience for the queue — appears largely uncontested. View restaurant →
12
Google
Pizza•New York•$$
Lucali
Mark Iacono's Carroll Gardens storefront has accumulated the kind of reputation that makes people build itineraries around a pizza dinner — which is, depending on your threshold for hype, either a warning or an endorsement.
Read restaurant page
9.9/10
TastyPals Score
8.4 Google
8.4
3,061 Google reviews
Explore next
Related guides
Google
Guide • new york
Best Restaurants in New York 2026
Ten New York restaurants that have earned their place through cooking, conviction, and the kind of staying power that survives every trend cycle — from a West Village Italian-American beloved since 2016 to a Lincoln Center tasting room that still sets the global standard.
Read guide
Guide • toronto
The 15 Best Date Night Restaurants in Toronto
The Toronto restaurants that make a date feel shaped, warm, and worth remembering without leaning too hard on cliché.
Read guide
Get the App
Save these spots to your New York list
Save these spots to your New York list in the TastyPals app, then explore similar restaurants when you want a tighter shortlist for the night.
Personalized city picksCleaner shortlistsBuilt for iPhone and Android
TastyPalsTonight
Your taste. Our picks.
Smarter follow-through after the guide: better restaurant context, quicker narrowing, less second-guessing.
For tonight
Date night spots with warm rooms and polished service
Next step
Keep exploring in the app when you want a tighter shortlist